![]() |
Back to School, Part 1 Bob's Backstop for August 30, 2005 |
A school somewhere in Baltimore County. “Mister Bryant” is written in cursive on the chalkboard at the front of the room. The room itself is abuzz with activity. A short, skinny boy dressed in an orange Orioles t-shirt is tossing spitballs at the clock, the gooey wads of paper finding their mark with a satisfying splat. A larger, barrel-chested boy with a Cheshire Cat grin cups his hand to a girl’s ear and whispers into it, only to be slapped when he leans back laughing at the completion of his story. All around the room, children are laughing and talking, except two. A dark-featured handsome little boy in the back of the room sits with his head back against the wall, his hands tucked under his thighs, wearing an expression of mild disgust. Two rows over from him, a tall girl sits up primly, looking around the room, efficiently scribbling into a loose-leaf notebook, a self-satisfied expression on her face.
“The new manager is an idiot!”
"Okay. Now, here you'll see the Runs Created by last year's offense at this same time period a year ago. Let's see if we can pinpoint some of the differences between this year and last year's, shall we? Drops of over a half run are highlighted in red, improvements of the same margin in orange:
| Position | Player 2004 | RC Sept 2004 | RC 2004 Final | Player 2005 | Current RC |
| Catcher | J. Lopez | 6.64 | 6.63 | J. Lopez | 5.23 |
| First Base | Palmeiro | 4.81 | 5.55 | Palmeiro | 5.47 |
| Second Base | Roberts | 5.20 | 4.86 | Roberts | 7.51 |
| Third Base | Mora | 9.22 | 8.62 | Mora | 5.47 |
| Shortstop | Tejada | 6.74 | 6.56 | Tejada | 6.67 |
| Left Field | Bigbie | 4.89 | 5.27 | Byrnes | 4.97 |
| Center Field | Hairston | 5.59 | DL | Matos | 5.34 |
| Right Field | Gibbons | 2.53 | 3.68 | Sosa | 3.36 |
| DH | Newhan | 8.07 | 6.29 | Gibbons | 4.59 |
| Utility IF | L. Lopez | 2.06 | 1.60 | Gomez | 3.87 |
| Fourth OF | Surhoff | 5.80 | 5.65 | Surhoff | 3.39 |
| Backup C | Merchado | 1.26 | 0.69 | Fasano | 4.80 |
| Fifth OF/DH | Garcia | 2.87 | Raines 3.00 | Newhan | 3.19 |
"When you look at what has happened to date this year, it's not that hard to see what some of the problem has been. Last season, three amazing things happened. Melvin Mora was not only a good player, but a player who put up a number that placed him among the top five players in the AL. David Newhan came off the scrap heap to play blistering baseball for six weeks, and then still better-than-average outfield numbers after that. B.J. Surhoff defied his age and put together a quiet but very effective season, helping to offset injuries and ineffectiveness on the part of other Orioles. None of those things should have been expected to reoccur, and none of them did.
"Mora came the closest. At the All-Star Break, he was creating around 6.5 runs per game, not the magic number of a year ago, but still very high. When Brian Roberts was putting up numbers close to those of Mora a year ago (he was at 9.93 at the break), the overall effect there was a wash from last year's production at 2B-SS-3B. Add in Palmeiro's improved numbers and Lopez'/Fasano's drop, but still respectable numbers, and things looked pretty good. But then Mora hurt his shoulder, his hand, and his ankle, and he hasn't been the same player since. Roberts has, as expected, regressed, and Palmeiro's suspension for testing positive for steroids has left Tejada and Lopez to carry the ball, and although both are hitting, neither is on fire, and neither is hitting home runs, something this station-to-station lower-OBP team needs to score runs.
"No one appeared from nowhere this season as Newhan did a year ago. Sal Fasano proved to be a better hitter than either of last year's backup catchers, but that is faint praise, indeed. The bench has been toothless all season, and Jay Gibbons has not parlayed a healthy season into anything hopeful. His isolated power looks decent, but if you can't get on base, you're slow, and you play bad defense, even at first base, you can't really be considered a real positive. Sammy Sosa's failure to break five runs a game was huge for this team...when he WAS at that level early in the year, the team was winning and scoring runs by the bushel basket, but once he began turning in numbers more in line with last year's RF production, things went south in a hurry.
"On average, the runs created numbers reflect about a half-run per game decline over last year's at the same time, and that's a significant number. It's hard to pinpoint it on one or two players. Mora would have been down at least two runs a game without the injuries, but Roberts will probably finish the year at least a run above his numbers of a year ago, if not a bit more than that. Lopez will not match last year's numbers in either quantity or quality, but his current output is respectable. Tejada is close to last year's numbers, though he'd be the first to bemoan his home runs totals dropping and his RBI production. Bigbig/Byrne, Hairston-Newhan/Matos, and Gibbons/Sosa is pretty much a wash, which is not a good thing considering the poor performance of 2004's outfield, and 2005's bench performance, with Surhoff's dropoff coupled with Gomez' superior play to that of Luis Lopez, is pretty much a wash, too.
"It appears that some of this is mental. Guys are trying too hard, expecting to fail, approaching the game all wrong, taking when they should swing, swinging when they should take. It's the nature of the beast when things go bad. The one thing we can hope for is a repeat of the finish of 2004. For all the rending of clothes and gnashing of teeth, if the O's repeated their 18-10 mark of a year ago this month, that would be an improvement over last year. And they looked as bad going into September last year as they do this year.
"I'm not suggesting that any of you children hold your breath in expectation, but anything is possible. Okay, that's it for today. Tomorrow, we'll take a look at the bullpen. Now it's time for recess. Play nice, children."